Episode 77: How She Grew Her Podcast Downloads 43% in 3 Months with Simple Strategies with Kellie Lupsha

43% Podcast Growth in 3 Months, Two Quiz Funnels, and the Data That Changed Everything: How One Midlife Wellness Podcaster Stopped Guessing and Started Growing

Listen on Apple Podcast | Listen on Spotify | Watch on YouTube

What happens when you stop guessing and start looking at your data?

My guest today, Kellie Lupsha, is living proof. Kellie is the host of Thriving in Midlife and the founder of a health and wellness business helping women navigate their 40s, 50s, and beyond. She is a former physical therapist turned entrepreneur who publishes two episodes a week, runs a women's membership and a 12-week intensive program, and recently built two quiz funnels that completely shifted what she knows about her audience.

Kellie was one of my students in my beta mastermind, and she is one of the best implementers I have ever worked with. After going through the program and making what she described as "not even a heavy lift," Kellie saw a 43% growth in downloads in just three months. Then she switched to Captivate as her hosting platform, applied everything she had learned about SEO, and matched four years of total downloads in just four months.

In this episode of Podcast Growth Tools, Kellie shares the micro tweaks that drove that growth, what surprised her most about her quiz data, how she manages two episodes a week without burning out, and her honest advice for anyone wondering whether podcasting is worth the long game commitment.

If you have been podcasting for a while and wondering what small shifts could make a real difference, this conversation is going to light you up.


Here's a glance to the episode:

  • How Kellie grew her podcast downloads by 43% in three months through micro tweaks

  • How she matched four years of total downloads in just four months after switching to Captivate and optimizing for SEO

  • The two biggest needle movers from my mastermind that Kellie implemented immediately

  • Why she built two quiz funnels and what the data revealed about her audience that she never expected

  • How she manages two podcast episodes per week while running multiple businesses

  • Why her first membership failed and how it led her to build a better podcast

  • The power of letting your podcast evolve (name changes, format shifts, and business model pivots)

  • Why raw, unpolished podcast content is connecting with female audiences more than ever

  • Her strategy for finding and vetting podcast guests through relationships instead of cold pitches

  • The advice she would give anyone thinking about starting a podcast

  • Why building an email list from day one is the number one thing she wishes she had done sooner

Timestamps:

  • 4:00: How she started podcasting during COVID and let the show evolve

  • 6:35: Why her first $19 membership failed and what it taught her

  • 7:30: How she realized her audience wanted conversations, not courses

  • 8:45: Letting your podcast name and format change without fear

  • 9:15: How she publishes two episodes per week

  • 10:05: Batching content, minimal editing, and hiring a VA

  • 12:05: Why raw and real content is winning with female audiences

  • 16:05: How her podcast feeds into her business

  • 16:30: Why she never looked at her analytics before the mastermind

  • 17:15: Her goal to guest on more podcasts in 2026

  • 18:05: Finding and vetting guests through relationships

  • 21:30: Creating content from program questions and real life experiences

  • 25:00: Why two or three conversations give you your best episode topics

  • 27:05: The two biggest aha moments from the mastermind

  • 27:25: SEO in podcast titles and show notes

  • 28:05: Why quizzes outperform traditional lead magnets

  • 28:30: How her first quiz drove leads and what she learned

  • 29:00: Building two new quizzes

  • 30:05: The quiz data surprise: what she expected vs. what happened

  • 31:05: How the quiz told her exactly who to create content for

  • 32:55: Why the curated quiz experience creates raving fans

  • 34:25: The growth results: 43% in three months, four years of downloads in four months

  • 36:05: Why monthly analytics tracking is now part of her workflow

  • 36:25: Advice for anyone thinking about starting a podcast

  • 37:00: The 10-episode test

  • 38:25: It is never crowded because nobody is in your space


If You're Asking These Questions, You're in the Right Place:

  • How do I grow my podcast without spending tons of time and money?

  • What small changes can I make to increase my podcast downloads?

  • How do I use a quiz to grow my podcast and email list?

  • How do I manage publishing two podcast episodes per week?

  • Is it okay to change my podcast name or format?

  • How do I know what content my audience actually wants?

  • How do I use podcast analytics to make better content decisions?

  • Should I start a podcast if I already have a business?


The Two Biggest Needle Movers: SEO Titles and Quiz Funnels

When I asked Kellie what the most impactful things she implemented were, she gave two answers immediately.

SEO-optimized titles and show notes. Before the mastermind, Kellie named her episodes whatever felt right in the moment. She did not realize the weight that titles and descriptions carry for discoverability on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Once she started running her titles through SEO analysis and writing keyword-rich descriptions, her episodes became findable by the exact people searching for the topics she covers. She credits this single shift as a major driver of her 43% growth.

Quiz funnels. Kellie built her first quiz inside the mastermind and used it as a lead magnet. She ran ads to it, and it successfully drove leads into one of her programs. But here is where it gets interesting: after sitting with the results, she realized she would design it differently. So she built two more. One is a product-based quiz for her supplements and wellness products. The other segments her audience into four types of midlife women and drives them into a masterclass that feeds her program.

The quiz data surprised her. She expected the results to be evenly distributed across all four buckets. Instead, one result dominated. Then there was a clear second winner. And the other two? Barely showed up. That data told her exactly who to create content for, which topics to prioritize, and where to focus her marketing energy. She would never have known that without the quiz.


43% Growth in 3 Months, Then 4 Years of Downloads in 4 Months

Kellie's growth story has two chapters.

First, after implementing SEO optimizations, better show notes, and her quiz funnel, she saw a 43% increase in downloads over three months. She emphasized that this was not a heavy lift. It was micro tweaks: better titles, better descriptions, a lead magnet that actually worked.

Then in January, she switched her hosting platform to Captivate. She applied everything she had learned about SEO optimization and content strategy. In just four months on Captivate, she matched the total downloads she had accumulated over the previous four years on her old platform.

The combination of clean data, SEO-friendly titles, and intentional content planning created a compounding effect. And now she tracks her analytics monthly, looking at what performed, what can be repurposed, and what topics deserve a part two.


How She Publishes Two Episodes Per Week Without Burning Out

Kellie's secret is simplicity. Her episodes are 10 to 15 minutes long. She batches them on Mondays, sometimes recording three or four in one sitting. She does minimal editing. And she has a VA who handles the back-end tech: getting transcripts done, uploading episodes, and publishing.

She also acknowledged that she is in a different season of life than many podcasters. Her four kids are all grown and out of the house, which gives her time and bandwidth. But the principles still apply regardless of your season: keep your episodes short and focused, batch when you can, outsource the tech, and do not over-edit. Her audience responds more to raw, real conversations than polished productions.


Why Her First Membership Failed and What It Taught Her

Kellie started a membership before her podcast. It was $19 a month, and she filled it by reaching out to everyone she knew. But she quickly realized she had overwhelmed her members with too much information. What they actually wanted was not a course with 50 modules. They wanted conversations. They wanted to feel like they were sitting with a friend having coffee.

That realization is what led her to commit to podcasting for good. The membership taught her that her audience valued the relationship and the conversation more than the content volume. She paused the membership and put that energy into building a podcast that delivered exactly what her audience craved.


Building an Email List from Day One

If Kellie could go back and give herself one piece of advice, it would be this: build an email list from the very first episode.

She started podcasting without a lead magnet, without an opt-in, without any way to capture the people who were listening. When she eventually wanted to launch something, she did not have a list of her most engaged listeners to sell to. She has since corrected this with her quiz funnels, but she was adamant that anyone starting a podcast should have some kind of opt-in from day one, whether that is a guide, a checklist, a quiz, or anything that gives people a reason to share their email address.


Advice for Anyone Thinking About Starting a Podcast

Kellie's advice is practical and honest. Podcasting is a long game. Before you commit, test yourself: can you record 10 episodes? You do not even have to publish them. Just see if you enjoy the process. If it stresses you out and you hate it, that is valuable information.

If you love it, know that you need to show up consistently. At minimum, publish weekly. Do not start and stop and start and stop. That cycle takes more energy than just staying consistent.

And her final piece of wisdom: it is never too late, and it is never too crowded. Nobody can be you, so your space is always open.


Your Next Steps

If you want weekly insights on podcast growth, marketing strategy, and turning listeners into subscribers, join the newsletter at:

www.podcastmarketinghub.com/subscribe

Take the Podcast Growth Quiz: www.podcastmarketinghub.com/quiz


Resources & Links

Connect with Kellie

Connect with Kylee


Let’s Connect!

Share your favorite trend from this episode or ask questions by DMing me on Instagram at @thepodcastmarketinghub.


Subscribe & Review

If you loved this episode, don’t forget to hit subscribe and leave a review! Reviews help more podcasters like you discover this show.

Next
Next

Episode 76: 11 Ways to Turn Old Podcast Episodes Into New Growth: Part 2