Episode 75: 11 Ways to Turn Old Podcast Episodes Into New Growth: Part 1

26 Million Downloads, 650+ Episodes, and a Quiz That Activates Her Entire Back Catalog: How Kelly Smith Built Mindful In Minutes Into a Long-Game Podcast Business

Listen on Apple Podcast | Listen on Spotify | Watch on YouTube

How many podcast episodes have you published? Maybe 50. Maybe 75. Maybe you are well over 100 at this point.

Now here is the real question, and I want you to be honest with yourself: when was the last time you actually did anything with those episodes after they went live?

If your answer is never, you are not alone. And you are sitting on a goldmine.

Every episode you have ever published has the potential to grow your email list, bring in new listeners, and drive people to your offers. But for most podcasters, those episodes are just sitting there collecting dust while you are too busy thinking about what is next.

What if the fastest way to grow your podcast right now is not to create more content, but to activate the content you have already made?

That is what this episode of Podcast Growth Tools is all about. This is Part 1 of a two-part series on how to activate your back catalog and make it work for your business. Today is all about the foundation: the strategic groundwork of auditing, optimizing, and setting everything up. In Part 2, I will show you how to turn your back catalog into leads, revenue, and some really creative things like podcast bundles, quizzes, private podcast experiences, and more.

Even if you only have 15 or 20 episodes, this is for you. You are actually at an advantage because you can start thinking ahead: if I plan and publish this episode today, how am I going to repurpose it in three months, six months, or two years?


Here's a glance to the episode:

  • How to audit your back catalog using your podcast analytics and AI

  • How to identify your top 10 evergreen winners and your bottom 10 underperformers

  • How to find patterns in your data that tell you exactly what your audience wants more of

  • Why your underperforming episodes probably have great content but bad packaging

  • How to rework titles and descriptions to give underperforming episodes a second life

  • Why episode descriptions are SEO real estate and how to optimize them

  • How to update your blog-style show notes for an organic traffic boost

  • How strategic re-airs let you stay consistent without recording new content

  • How to create a curated listening path that turns your back catalog into a sales funnel

  • Why one afternoon of updates can produce a noticeable bump in organic traffic within weeks

Timestamps:

  • 01:50: Part 1 of a two-part series: the strategic foundation

  • 03:15: Step 1: Audit your back catalog

  • 04:50: How to identify your top 10 evergreen winners

  • 05:15: Why you need to look at your bottom 10 (this is where the opportunities hide)

  • 05:40: Finding patterns: solo vs. interviews, topics, episode length

  • 06:30: Which platforms to pull your data from

  • 07:00: How to check which episodes are driving action (Google Analytics, quiz opt-ins, website traffic)

  • 08:00: Step 2: Optimize your underperforming episodes

  • 08:50: Why great content with bad packaging gets ignored

  • 09:10: Before and after: "My thoughts on making money" vs. a keyword-rich title

  • 09:55: Reworking your episode descriptions for SEO

  • 10:30: Adding tags and keywords in your hosting platform

  • 11:00: Why this is the lowest effort, highest reward thing you can do

  • 11:10: Real results: episodes going from 30 downloads to 150-200 just from a title and description change

  • 11:20: Step 3: Update your blog-style show notes on your website

  • 12:15: Adding internal links between episodes

  • 12:45: Refreshing old CTAs with current offers

  • 13:25: Beefing up thin show notes into full blog posts

  • 14:05: Step 4: Strategic re-airs

  • 14:45: How to record a fresh intro and updated CTA

  • 15:15: Three use cases: launch weeks, maternity leave, and seasonal relevance

  • 16:30: Step 5: Creating a curated listening path

  • 17:00: The five-episode listening path framework

  • 18:35: How to use the listening path on sales pages, in DMs, and in email sequences

  • 19:30: Three ways to deliver the listening path: bundles, re-releases, or private podcasts

  • 19:45: Recap and homework before Part 2


If You're Asking These Questions, You're in the Right Place:

  • What should I do with my old podcast episodes?

  • How do I get more downloads on episodes I have already published?

  • How do I optimize old podcast episodes for SEO?

  • Can I republish or re-air old podcast episodes?

  • How do I turn my podcast into a sales funnel?

  • How do I use my podcast back catalog to grow my email list?

  • How do I audit my podcast analytics?

  • What is a curated listening path and how do I create one?


Step 1: Audit Your Back Catalog

Before you can activate your back catalog, you need to know what you are working with. Pull up your podcast analytics from your hosting platform (Captivate, Buzzsprout, or whatever you use), and if possible, also pull from Spotify for Creators and Apple Podcasts Connect. The more data sources you pull, the more complete your picture will be.

Here is what to look for.

Your top 10 episodes. Not just by total downloads, but which episodes consistently get played months after they went live. These are your evergreen winners. They are clearly resonating with people long after you published them.

Your bottom 10 episodes. Nobody likes looking at these, but this is where some of the biggest opportunities are hiding. More on that in a minute.

Patterns. Are your solo episodes outperforming interviews? Are episodes about a specific topic (like email list growth or monetization) consistently getting more plays? Are shorter episodes doing better than longer ones? This data tells you exactly what your audience wants from you, and it will inform everything you do moving forward.

Which episodes are driving action. If you have Google Analytics set up on your website and you have blog-style show notes, check which pages are getting the most traffic. If you have a quiz or a freebie, check which episodes are driving the most opt-ins. This shows you not just what people are listening to, but what is actually moving the needle in your business.

Your homework: open a spreadsheet (or a notebook), write down your top 10 and bottom 10 with their download numbers, and note any patterns. You can also upload your data into AI and have it analyze the patterns for you.


Step 2: Optimize Your Underperforming Episodes

Here is something I have learned from working with podcasters for years: a lot of times an episode underperforms not because the content is bad, but because the packaging is off.

Think about it this way. You could have the most incredible, life-changing episode about podcast monetization. But if the title is something vague like "My Thoughts on Making Money," nobody is going to click on that. Nobody is searching for that. The content might be gold, but the wrapper does not tell your listener what is inside quickly enough for them to decide to press play.

Here is what to do with those underperforming episodes.

Rework the titles. Make them keyword-rich and specific. Instead of "My Thoughts on Making Money," try "3 Podcast Monetization Strategies That Actually Work for Female Entrepreneurs." The difference is massive. The second title tells the listener exactly what they are going to learn, includes searchable keywords, and makes it about them instead of about you.

Rework the descriptions. Your episode description is SEO real estate, especially on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. If your descriptions are one sentence long or super generic, you are leaving organic discoverability on the table. Go back and write descriptions that include relevant keywords, clearly state what the listener will learn, and give people a reason to press play.

Add tags and keywords. Some hosting platforms allow you to add tags and keywords for individual episodes. Go back to those underperformers and make sure you are using that feature.

This is probably the lowest effort, highest reward thing you can do with your back catalog. You are not recording anything new. You are not creating new content. You are just changing the packaging on content that already exists. I have seen clients do this and watched episodes go from 30 downloads to 150 or 200 just from a title and description change. The algorithm can finally find it. People searching for that topic can finally discover it.


Step 3: Update Your Blog-Style Show Notes

If you have show notes on your website, this is one of those things most podcasters are not doing but should be. Here is how to update them.

Add internal links. Maybe an older episode connects naturally to a newer episode that was not published at the time you wrote those original show notes. Link them together. This keeps people on your website longer, which helps Google understand more about your site.

Refresh your CTAs. Your CTAs might be eight months old or might be driving traffic to something you no longer prioritize. Maybe you have a quiz now or a newer freebie or a newer offer. Go back and update those calls to action so they are relevant.

Beef up thin show notes. If your show notes were originally just a few sentences with some timestamps, consider going back and turning them into full blog posts. Add subheads, keywords, a summary of key takeaways, and links to resources you mentioned. Google does not care when your content was published. It wants to see depth and relevance.

If you spend one afternoon updating the show notes on your top 10 episodes, you can see a noticeable bump in organic traffic within a few weeks. That is the power of SEO.


Step 4: Strategic Re-Airs

You have episodes in your catalog that crushed it. Great downloads, great opt-ins, people sent you DMs about them. Why would you let those episodes live in an archive where only the most dedicated binge listeners might find them?

Re-air them, but do it strategically. Record a fresh 60 to 90 second intro where you frame why you are resharing the episode and what makes it relevant right now. Play the original episode. Then tack on an updated CTA at the end.

Three great use cases for strategic re-airs.

Launch weeks. If you are about to open the doors to an offer, re-air an episode that aligns with that offer's topic. It warms up your audience perfectly without you starting from scratch.

When you need a break. Whether it is maternity leave, illness, or just a full season of life, a strategic re-air lets you stay consistent without recording a new episode.

Seasonal relevance. If you did an incredible episode on Q4 planning last year, re-air it when Q4 rolls around again. The content is evergreen, your new listeners have not heard it, and your loyal listeners might appreciate hearing it again.

The key is that you are not secretly republishing an old episode and hoping nobody notices. You are being intentional about it. You are framing it, updating the CTA, and choosing to reshare it in a moment that makes strategic sense for your business.


Step 5: Create a Curated Listening Path

This is where your back catalog becomes a sales tool.

If you have a course, coaching program, or membership that solves a specific set of problems for your audience, chances are you have multiple episodes in your catalog that address those exact same problems. You have been teaching those topics for months, maybe years.

What if you created a curated listening path? A sequence of three to five episodes that you recommend people listen to in order, designed to walk them from awareness to purchase.

Here is what the sequence might look like.

Episode 1: The awareness episode. This is where they realize they have the problem. You call it out. You name the problem that your offer solves.

Episode 2: The deeper dive. This is where they start to understand why they have the problem and what has been keeping them stuck.

Episode 3: The possibility episode. Maybe this is a client interview or a case study. Something that shows them what is possible on the other side.

Episode 4: The quick win episode. Give them something they can implement right away that gives them a taste of what your full offer delivers.

Episode 5: The CTA episode. This is where you share your offer and invite them in.

You can mix and match from your back catalog. Maybe three of those episodes already exist and you only need to record one or two new ones. Then you put the listening path on your sales page, include it in your email welcome sequence, or DM it to leads: "Hey, if you are curious about working with me, I have a curated playlist that will give you a great sense of what we do. Start here."

By the time they get to the offer, they already trust you. They have been listening to you for hours. They feel like they know you. You can deliver this as a bundle, re-release the episodes fresh on your podcast feed, or set it up as a private podcast experience.


Recap: Your Homework Before Part 2

  1. Audit your catalog. Get to know your top performers, your underperformers, and the patterns in your data.

  2. Optimize your underperforming episodes by reworking titles, descriptions, and keywords.

  3. Update your show notes on your website with internal links, refreshed CTAs, and beefed-up content.

  4. Identify episodes that are strong candidates for strategic re-airs.

  5. Start thinking about a curated listening path that could lead listeners to your offer.

In Part 2 (dropping in two weeks), we are going to take everything you have uncovered and turn it into podcast bundles, quizzes, private podcast experiences, freebies, and more. You are going to need to know what you are working with to make the most of it, so go do that audit before then.


Your Next Steps

If you want weekly insights on podcast growth, marketing strategy, and turning listeners into subscribers, join the newsletter at:

www.podcastmarketinghub.com/subscribe


Resources & Links

Connect with Kylee


Let’s Connect!

Share your favorite trend from this episode or ask questions by DMing me on Instagram at @thepodcastmarketinghub.


Subscribe & Review

If you loved this episode, don’t forget to hit subscribe and leave a review! Reviews help more podcasters like you discover this show.

Previous
Previous

Episode 76: 11 Ways to Turn Old Podcast Episodes Into New Growth: Part 2

Next
Next

Episode 74: 26 Million Downloads Later: The Podcast Growth Strategy That Actually Works with Kelly Smith of Mindful in Minutes