Episode 72: What Top Female Podcasters Are ACTUALLY Talking About (It's Not Downloads)

What the Most Successful Female Podcasters Are Actually Talking About in 2026 (5 Takeaways from the Podcasting Moms Conference in Nashville)

Listen on Apple Podcast | Listen on Spotify | Watch on YouTube

Picture this. You walk into a room in Nashville and it is filled with women who get it.

Women who know what it is like to pour their heart into a microphone week after week. Women who are building businesses, raising families, chasing big goals, and doing it all with a podcast as their main piece of long-form content.

That was me one week ago at the Podcasting Moms Conference, hosted by two incredible human beings, Cait Howard and Amanda Bennett. I spoke on a panel, and I am not going to lie, I walked in a bundle of nerves. I looked to my left and looked to my right at the other panelists and thought, what am I doing here? These women have done amazing things. But once I got into conversations with them, none of them were doing it all. They were doing what made sense, what moved the needle, and what felt good enough to give them a life that was not all just work.

In this episode of Podcast Growth Tools, I am sharing my five biggest takeaways from being in that room. These are the conversations that are actually happening among female podcasters who are building real businesses with their shows right now. And I think some of them are going to challenge you in the best way.


Here's a glance to the episode:

  • Why the most successful female podcasters have stopped talking about download numbers

  • The metric shift that matters more than total downloads for your business

  • Why collaboration is still the single most effective podcast growth strategy

  • How AI is changing the game for women podcasters and why most of us are still using it at surface level

  • Why audiences are craving raw, real, unpolished podcast experiences in 2026

  • What Holly Haynes shared about where the majority of her business growth comes from

  • A challenge you can take on this week to start shifting how you measure success

Timestamps:

  • 00:00 - Walking into a room full of female podcasters in Nashville

  • 01:15 - Speaking on the panel and the comparison trap

  • 03:05 - Takeaway 1: Impact over vanity metrics

  • 06:12 - Takeaway 2: Conversions over downloads

  • 08:49 - Takeaway 3: Nothing beats collaboration

  • 12:52 - Takeaway 4: Women need to have bigger conversations about AI

  • 16:08 - Takeaway 5: People are craving real podcast experiences

  • 20:16 - Recap of all five takeaways

  • 21:04 - How to stay connected and share this episode


If You're Asking These Questions, You're in the Right Place:

  • What are the biggest podcasting trends for women in 2026?

  • How do I stop comparing my podcast numbers to other podcasters?

  • What matters more than downloads for a podcast-driven business?

  • How do I use collaboration to grow my podcast?

  • How should female podcasters be using AI in their business?

  • Do podcast episodes need to be perfectly edited to grow an audience?


Takeaway 1: Impact Over Vanity Metrics

This one set the tone for the entire conference.

When you put a room full of female podcasters together, from women who have been doing this since 2015 with millions of downloads to women who are just starting with maybe 20 downloads an episode, the one thing nobody was talking about was their download numbers.

The conversation was about the listener who sent a DM saying your episode changed how I run my business. The woman who finally launched her offer because something you said gave her the push she needed. The email that came in from someone who said I have listened to every single episode and I am signing up for your program.

That is what is happening for podcasters who are in it for the long run, who see the bigger picture, and who are committed to creating something with real legs. Especially for female entrepreneurs who are using their podcast as the cornerstone of their marketing, it is not about how big the number is. It is about how deep the impact goes.

Metrics still matter. You should still track them and understand which direction they are moving. But they are not the end all be all. If you have been feeling discouraged because your numbers are not where you want them to be, start paying attention to the messages in your inbox. Pay attention to who is showing up in your world because of what you said on your show. That is the real metric.


Takeaway 2: Conversions Over Downloads

This one builds directly on the first.

You can have a thousand downloads on an episode, but if none of those listeners are doing anything beyond pressing play, there is a problem. And that was a huge piece of the conversation at the conference. Women were asking bigger, better questions. Not just "how do I get more downloads?" but "where do my episodes actually lead? How well are my listeners converting into email subscribers? How am I leading them to my offers? What does the data actually show me?"

That is a completely different conversation. And it is a much more powerful one.

You do not need one million listeners to have a thriving business. When you start tracking conversions, you begin to see the true power of your show. Sometimes one episode with 200 downloads brings in 40 new email subscribers, while another episode with 800 downloads brings in five. That data is pure gold.

Here is the challenge. Go look at your numbers this week, but not just your download metrics. Look at your email list growth. Look at your click-through rates from your show notes. Look at how many people are actually moving from listener to subscriber to buyer. Ask the people who are buying how they found you. I am guessing a lot of them will say the podcast, probably more than you think.


Takeaway 3: Nothing Beats Collaboration

I could talk about this one for an hour because it has me so fired up. And it is not new. This is the same tried and true strategy that has worked long before COVID, long before everything. But I need you to hear it differently today.

What I experienced in Nashville was not just networking. It was not surface-level business card swapping energy. It was women genuinely pouring into each other. Sharing what is working. Being honest about what is not. Opening doors for each other without any expectation of something in return.

The women whose podcasts are growing the fastest are not doing it alone. They are the ones who are deep in community with other female entrepreneurs and podcasters. They are doing podcast swaps, going into each other's communities, doing trainings, speaking at conferences together, connecting each other with guests, sharing content, and talking about more than just business. They are talking about life.

Holly Haynes was a speaker at the conference and showed a graph of where the majority of her business growth comes from. A huge portion was speaking at conferences and collaborating with other entrepreneurs.

We were not meant to build our businesses in a silo. Just like we were never meant to raise kids completely alone, we should not be building businesses alone either. That is the hard way. It is exhausting. It is mentally and physically draining. And your numbers will suffer because of it.

If you are not currently in community with other female entrepreneurs and podcasters, whether that is a live event, an online community, a mastermind, or even just a group of five women on Zoom, find your people. Reach out to somebody whose podcast you admire. Pitch a podcast swap. Offer to do a training in their community. The growth that comes from collaborating will outpace anything you can do alone.


Takeaway 4: Women Need to Have Bigger Conversations About AI

This one hits close to my heart, and it is the reason I created the AI Edition Podcast Glow-Up Party.

Here is what I am seeing. Women are using AI, and that is great. A lot of us are using it to simplify our lives and in our businesses to draft social captions, brainstorm episode topics, and outline content. But most of us are still using it at a surface level. We are asking basic questions, copying and pasting whatever it spits out, and wondering why our content sounds a little off and why people are not converting.

Platforms like Claude allow you to train AI to write closer to your voice than ever before. You can feed it your brand documents, your past content, your tone preferences, and suddenly it is not giving you generic output. It is giving you something that actually sounds like you. Beyond writing, you can use AI to design faster, repurpose smarter, build systems that clear your plate, and set up automated tasks so you can focus on what you do best: showing up for your audience and creating incredible content.

But here is the key. We are not handing it over to the robot. We are not being lazy about it. We are being intentional. We are learning the tools, building the prompts, and staying in the driver's seat.

The podcasters who figure this out are going to have more bandwidth, create better content in less time, and have space to actually enjoy the process again instead of feeling buried in a to-do list every single week. As women, we owe it to ourselves to not just dabble in AI but to really learn it.


Takeaway 5: People Are Craving Real Podcast Experiences

This might be my favorite takeaway, and I alluded to it at the very beginning of this episode when I showed up congested and stuffed up from a sinus infection.

For years, the standard of podcasting has been perfectly polished, perfectly edited audio where every "um" is removed, every pause is cut, and every background noise is eliminated. And there is nothing wrong with a well-produced show. That is not what I am saying. But what came up over and over at this conference was that the shows building the most loyal audiences right now, especially with female listeners, are the ones that feel real.

The ones where the host's kids walk in during a recording and she handles it naturally. Where the conversation goes off on a tangent because something came up that was too good not to talk about. Where it sounds like you are sitting across the table from a best friend having coffee, not listening to a rehearsed TED Talk.

The world has gotten really noisy with perfectly curated content. Perfect Instagram feeds, perfect reels, AI-generated everything. And people are over it. They can feel the difference between somebody who is performing and somebody who is being themselves. And they are choosing real every time.

Now, I want to be clear. This is not permission to banter for an hour and not deliver value. You still need intentionality behind your episodes. You still need to deliver what you promise. But it is okay to let the real moments happen. Record the episode where your dog barks in the background. Leave in the moment where you lost your train of thought and laugh about it. Share what is actually going on in your life. That is what is connecting with audiences right now, and I do not think it is going away anytime soon.


The Recap

  1. Impact over vanity metrics. Focus on the lives you are changing, not just the numbers.

  2. Conversions over downloads. Start tracking where your episodes actually lead.

  3. Nothing beats collaboration. Find your people, pour into them, and watch what happens.

  4. Women need to have bigger conversations about AI. Stop dabbling and start using it intentionally.

  5. People are craving real podcast experiences. Be yourself. Your audience is going to love you for it.


Your Next Steps

If you want weekly insights on podcast growth, marketing strategy, and turning listeners into subscribers, join the newsletter here


Resources & Links

Connect with Kylee


Let’s Connect!

Share your favorite trend from this episode or ask questions by DMing me on Instagram at @thepodcastmarketinghub.


Subscribe & Review

If you loved this episode, don’t forget to hit subscribe and leave a review! Reviews help more podcasters like you discover this show.

Previous
Previous

Episode 73: 3 Marketing Mistakes Killing Your Podcast & Business Growth (+ What to Do Instead) with Megan Yelaney

Next
Next

Episode 71: Why Going Viral Is Overrated (& What Actually Grows Your Business on Social Media + Beyond) with Kristina Bartold